Shorts case studies · 2026-10-05

“1 Minute Through Comments” (댓글로 보는 1분) — 99 Vertical Shorts Pairing a Performance's Peak Minute with Its Best Comments

The best minute of a live singing performance plus 4–6 of its most-liked comments. We take apart a vertical 60-second series in which the comments choose both the segment and the title.

“1 Minute Through Comments” (댓글로 보는 1분) — 99 Vertical Shorts Pairing a Performance's Peak Minute with Its Best Comments

The YouTube playlist “1 Minute Through Comments” (댓글로 보는 1분) is a vertical Shorts series that takes the best minute of a singing performance and overlays the most-liked comments posted under that performance as cards. As of October 5, 99 videos have been posted. The playlist description sums up the series in one sentence — “The songs are great, but some performances only feel complete once you've read the comments.”

Hwasa “Maria” at Rock in Rio 2026 Hwasa “Maria” at Rock in Rio 2026 Hwasa “Good Goodbye” at the Blue Dragon Film Awards Hwasa “Good Goodbye” at the Blue Dragon Film Awards Petra Tyler “Inyeon (Fate)” cover Petra Tyler “Inyeon (Fate)” cover Hwasa “Maria” at Livewire Hwasa “Maria” at Livewire

Anatomy of a video — vertical, 60 seconds, 4–6 comment cards

Every video is 1080×1920 vertical and about 60 seconds long. It captures the continuous minute building to the climax of the original performance and overlays 4–6 comments, chosen by number of likes, as cards. The “Maria” Rock in Rio 2026 video opens with the ‘Brasil!’ shout and the first chorus, passes through the dance break, and closes with the final chorus sung along by the crowd, plus fireworks. The comment cards are colored in crimson and plum tones to match the stage lighting, and during the climax the cards are pulled so the stage can speak for itself. It's a rule that minimizes the moments when comments cover the screen.

The comments choose which minute to use

Comments are also what decide the segment. We look for the moments people left as timestamps and use those points.

  • Ma I-jin (마이진), “Shaken Friendship” (흔들린 우정) — from the 1:24 highlight picked out in the comments through to the climax
  • Brown Eyed Girls, “Abracadabra” — 1:00 and 2:00, the moments commenters replayed the most
  • Petra Tyler, “Inyeon (Fate)” (인연) — from the end of the second verse to the final high-note climax

The title: “Song name” — the one moment the comments remember

After the song name, the title adds the scene that makes the performance memorable in one line — for example, “Lee Hyuk ‘TEARS’ — the high note that broke the comments first,” “Ali ‘Don't Worry, Dear’ (걱정말아요 그대) — the performance the comments called ‘irreplaceable’,” and “Kim Wan-sun ‘Let's Forget Now’ (이젠 잊기로 해요) — the night the whole audience sang along.” The description includes the performance details (event, year), a few of the comments featured in the video with their like counts (e.g. ♥5,500), and the source (the original channel or broadcast).

What got a response

As of October 5, the “Maria” Rock in Rio 2026 video has about 54,000 views and 900 likes, and the “Good Goodbye” video from the Blue Dragon Film Awards celebratory performance (Park Jeong-min's ‘Goodbye’ after being handed the mic) has about 8,200 views. Videos with a moment anyone would recognize on a big stage (a crowd singalong, a singer stepping down into the audience) came out ahead. The range is wide — from Uhm Jung-hwa's “Poison” (1998) and Yoo Seung-jun's “Passion” (열정) on the 1999 “Music Camp” (음악캠프) to ZARD, 松任谷由実, 阿悠悠, Miley Cyrus and a J.Fla cover — regardless of era or language.

How it relates to Somssii Shorts

This series is an example made in the comment Shorts format of the video production line behind Somssii Shorts. Because this format uses original performance footage, every video credits its source. The Somssii Shorts that members make themselves (shopping, business promotion, Instagram, YouTube highlights, live) don't cut up the source video; they're created fresh from a one-line request and the content of the reference URLs. If you'd like to run a series like this consistently for your channel, get in touch.

Make Shorts → · Ask about a channel series →

Views 10
Shorts · Ten looks · Series

A Shorts video, a storyboard, design drafts or a series — start right now

Get free credits as soon as you sign up. No credit card required.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Be the first to get new concept packs, Shorts case studies, use cases, and generation tips.

✦Create ✎Contact

Sign up and get 30 free credits (3 sets) · No credit card needed

Start free